Health Crisis In Sandy Disaster Zones
Health Crisis In Sandy Disaster Zones: Cold, Mold Loom As Hazards In Rockaways, Staten Island, Elsewhere
By DAVID B. CARUSO 12/01/12 03:45 PM ET EST
NEW YORK — A month after Sandy’s floodwaters swept up his block, punched a hole in his foundation and drowned his furnace, John Frawley still has no electricity or heat in his dilapidated home on the Rockaway seashore.
The 57-year-old, who also lost his car and all his winter clothes in the flood, now spends his nights shivering in a pair of donated snow pants, worrying whether the cold might make his chronic heart condition worse.
“I’ve been coughing like crazy,” said Frawley, a former commercial fisherman disabled by a spine injury. He said his family doesn’t have the money to pay for even basic repairs. So far, he has avoided going to a shelter, saying he’d rather sleep in his own home.
“But I’m telling you, I can’t stay here much longer,” he said.
City officials estimate at least 12,000 New Yorkers are trying to survive in unheated, flood-damaged homes, despite warnings that dropping temperatures could pose a health risk.
The chill is only one of the potential environmental hazards that experts say might endanger people trying to resume their lives in the vast New York and New Jersey disaster zone.
Uncounted numbers of families have returned to coastal homes that are contaminated with mold, which can aggravate allergies and leave people perpetually wheezing. Others have been sleeping in houses filled with construction dust, as workers have ripped out walls and flooring. That dust can sometimes trigger asthma.
But it is the approaching winter that has some public health officials worried most. Nighttime temperatures have been around freezing and stand to drop in the coming weeks.
New York City’s health department said the number of people visiting hospital emergency rooms for cold-related problems has already doubled this November, compared with previous years. Those statistics are likely only the proverbial tip of the iceberg.
Mortality rates for the elderly and chronically ill rise when people live for extended periods in unheated apartments, even when the temperature is still above freezing, said the city’s health commissioner, Dr. Thomas Farley.
“As the temperatures get colder, the risk increases,” he said. “It is especially risky for the elderly. I really want to encourage people, if they don’t have heat in their apartment, to look elsewhere.”
Since the storm, the health department has been sending National Guard troops door to door, trying to persuade people to leave cold homes until their heating systems are fixed. The city is also carrying out a plan to spend hundreds of millions of dollars helping residents make emergency repairs needed to restore their heat and hot water.
Convincing people that they could be endangering themselves by staying until that work is complete, though, isn’t always easy.
For weeks, Eddie Saman, 57, slept on sheets of plywood in the frigid, ruined shell of his flooded Staten Island bungalow. He stayed even as the house filled up with a disgusting mold that agitated his asthma so much that it sent him to the emergency room.
Volunteers eventually helped clean the place up somewhat and got Saman a mattress. But on Sunday the wood-burning stove he had been using for heat caught fire.
Melting materials in the ceiling burned his cheek. A neighbor who dashed into the house to look for Saman also suffered burns. The interior of the house – what was left of it after the flood – was destroyed.
Two days later, another fire broke out in a flood-damaged house across the street, also occupied by a resident trying to keep warm without a working furnace.
Asked why he hadn’t sought lodging elsewhere, Saman said he didn’t have family in the region and was rattled by the one night he spent in an emergency shelter. He said it seemed more populated by homeless drug addicts than displaced families.
“That place was not for me,” he said.
The Federal Emergency Management Agency offered to pay for a hotel, but Saman said he stopped looking because every inn within 100 miles of the city seemed to be booked solid through December.
Saman’s case may be extreme, but experts said it isn’t unusual for people to hurry back to homes not ready for habitation.
After Hurricane Katrina, medical researchers in New Orleans documented a rise in respiratory ailments among people living in neighborhoods where buildings were being repaired.
The issue wasn’t just mold, which can cause problems for years if it isn’t mediated properly, said Felicia Rabito, an epidemiologist at Tulane University’s School of Public Health and Tropical Medicine. There was simply so much work being done, families spent their days breathing the fine particles of sanded wood and drywall.
People complained of something that became known as the “Katrina cough,” and while it subsided once the dust settled, researchers later found high lead levels in some neighborhoods due to work crews ignoring standards for lead paint removal.
A group of occupational health experts in New York City, including doctors who run programs for people sickened by World Trade Center dust after 9/11, warned last week that workers cleaning up Sandy’s wreckage need to protect themselves by suppressing dust with water, wearing masks and being aware of potential asbestos exposure.
“There are clearly sites that you don’t want children at … and it is very challenging for homeowners to know whether it is safe to go home,” said Dr. Maida Galvez, a pediatrician and environmental health expert at The Mount Sinai Hospital who is part of a team evaluating hazards in the disaster zone.
U.S. Rep. Jerrold Nadler has urged FEMA and the Environmental Protection Agency to develop a testing program that could give residents an indication of whether their homes were free of mold, sewage and other hazardous substances.
Farley, New York City’s health commissioner, said people entering rooms contaminated by floodwater should wear rubber boots and gloves, and exercise care in cleanup. The hazard posed by spilled sewage is a short-term one and experts say the disease-causing bacteria found in it can be wiped out with a good cleaning. But they say anything absorbent that touched tainted water, like curtains or rugs, should be thrown out.
As for the bitter cold, there was no test needed to tell John Frawley that his home is no place to be spending frigid autumn nights.
“A couple of days ago, I was shivering so badly, I just couldn’t stop,” he said.
Yet with winter nearly here, he still had no plan for getting his heat working again or his ruined electrical system restored, although he also has passed up some of the programs designed to help people like him.
And he has no intention of heading to a shelter.
One month after Sandy
ROUGH CUT (NO REPORTER NARRATION) STORY: One month after Superstorm Sandy leveled parts of Staten Island, a massive clean-up effort continues as residents clear out homes damaged or destroyed by the storm. Sandy slammed ashore on October 29, bringing a record storm surge and killing more than 120 people, 22 of those casualties from Staten Island. On New York City’s Staten Island, hundreds of homes remain damaged. Inspectors have tagged homes that are no longer inhabitable. And dozens of vehicles are still abandoned on gutted streets. Brett Gordon continued to clear out his Staten Island bungalow on Thursday (November 29). Gordon, his wife and two daughters lived in the home for about five years. Gordon has vowed to rebuild, but says he needs help. Gordon, a Manhattan doorman, said he feels abandoned by the local, state and national governments. “I believe God is good, but I can tell you one thing, the government isn’t good. That I can tell you, because if the government was good they’d be here assisting us. If they could give countries billions of dollars on the drop of a hat, why can’t they help the blue-collar Americans. I’m almost 40 years old, I’ve paid taxes since I was 14 on the books. Why can’t they treat me with dignity?” As he cleared out the home, Gordan said he has already talked to an architect to rebuild the home higher off the ground. “Come and assess some of these houses to see the trauma and the stigma that’s left with it for the children. Forget about me. I’m 40 years old. I’m a grown man, blue-collar guy, but what about my wife whose emotionally a mess? What about my children who are a mess. It’s not right. It’s not right the way they are treating us and I never asked for a handout. I don’t want a handout. I just want them to do the right thing for the community. We’re not a third world country. We are supposed to be one of the superpowers of the world, but I could tell you right now Britain wouldn’t let this happen.” In addition to the costs of rebuilding the home, the Gordon family is now renting an apartment to live until the home is fixed. The summer resort towns along the New Jersey shore were devoured by the massive storm. In Seaside Heights, Sandy brought several feet of water across the width of the island from the sea to the bay after it slammed ashore on October 29. At Casino Pier, one of the amusement parks along the 16-block boardwalk, the Star Jet roller coaster is still partially submerged offshore, its tracks a maze of twisted metal. The wooden boardwalk was buckled and swollen, and the beach littered with shorn electrical wires, slabs of broken concrete and shattered planks. Work crews continued to clear the debris. Al Zoloo, who was working to repair his home said, “You should have seen it the first day they let us in. It just reminded me of those movies, those futuristic movies where everybody died of a virus or something and you walk around and there is nobody around. That’s pretty much how it’s been.” Tens of thousands of people remain displaced by the storm.